Findymail vs Icypeas: Which Email Finder Is the Right Fit for Your Needs?

In short, Icypeas offers better value for money. While Findymail and Icypeas have similar performance in terms of find rate, accuracy, and speed, Icypeas is 2.5 times more cost-effective and provides a much more flexible credit system.

‍

Why salespeople are making the switch from Findymail to Icypeas

Here are the 3 key differences between Findymail and Icypeas:

Comparison Cards

📈

Performance

Icypeas and Findymail are neck and neck when it comes to email find rate, bounce rate, and processing speed.

💎

Pricing

Findymail is approximately 2.5 times more expensive than Icypeas (for the same data quality).

🪙

Credit system

Icypeas offers a much more flexible credit system.

‍

Feature comparison — Findymail vs Icypeas:

Feature	Icypeas	Findymail
Email Enrichment
Email Find Rate	✅ 79%	✅ 79.5%
Email Bounce Rate	✅ 1.3%	✅ 2.7%
Catchall Verification	✅	✅
Price Per Found Email	✅ Starts at $0.019	❌ Starts at $0.049
Processing Speed	✅ 2.3 sec / email	✅ 2.1 sec / email
Credit Rules
Credits Rollover	✅ Even if you cancel your plan	❌ Only if you keep your plan
Credits Never Expire	✅	❌
Uncapped Credit Stacking	✅	❌ Limited to 2x your plan's credit amount
Integrations
API	✅	✅
Clay	✅	✅
n8n	✅	❌
Make	✅	✅
Zapier	✅	✅
Apify	✅	❌

‍

As shown in the table above, Icypeas has a broader functional scope than Findymail.

‍

Findymail: An in-depth analysis

‍

‍

Pros and cons of Findymail

➕	➖
Findymail offers good quality data	Findymail is 2.5 more expensive than Icypeas.
Findymail has an Apollo.io lead scraper	Findymail locks its customers into a very restrictive credit system.

‍

Take away: Findymail is a good tool but it is too pricy. Icypeas is a much better option, offering the same performance at a far more affordable price.

‍

Icypeas: An in-depth analysis

‍

‍

Pros and cons of Icypeas

➕	➖
Icypeas offers good quality data.	Icypeas has no CRM connectors (yet).
Icypeas is 2.5 times more cost-effective than Findymail.	Icypeas has no "Phone Finder" feature (ETA: 2025-Q4).
Icypeas offers a "Find People" feature.
Icypeas API has a rate limit of 5000 email searches per second (Findymail: 300/sec).

‍

Take away: when looking at email enrichment, Icypeas is a better choice than Findymail.

‍

Icypeas vs Findymail: Which one is the best email finder tool?

From every angle, as an email finder, Icypeas is either equivalent to or better than Findymail.

That’s why Icypeas has often been preferred over Findymail by top-tier GTM products like LGM, Kanbox, Lemlist, Prosp, etc., to be placed at the top of their enrichment waterfalls.

You can find their testimonials here.

To form your own opinion, take advantage of the free trials from Icypeas and Findymail to enrich a test file.

Happy prospecting!

Anymail finder vs Icypeas: Which Email Finder To Choose?